Is Your Website Actually Working? How to Tell Without Being a Tech Expert

/ Uncategorized / By

Is Your Website Actually Working? How to Tell Without Being a Tech Expert

Most small business owners have a vague sense that their website “should be doing more” — but they don’t know how to measure whether it’s actually performing or sitting there costing them money. Here’s a plain-English guide to checking if your website is working, using free tools that take minutes to set up.

What “Working” Actually Means

A website is “working” when it:

  • Gets found by people searching for what you offer
  • Convinces those visitors that you’re the right choice
  • Makes it easy for them to contact you

If you’re getting traffic but no enquiries, the problem is conversion. If you’re getting no traffic, the problem is visibility. Knowing which problem you have tells you where to focus.

Step 1: Check If You’re Getting Traffic — Google Analytics 4

Google Analytics 4 (GA4) is free and shows you how many people are visiting your website, where they’re coming from, and which pages they visit.

What to check:

  • Total users per month: A local service business should be getting at least 100–500 visitors/month from organic search. Less than 50/month suggests an SEO problem.
  • Traffic source: Go to Reports > Acquisition > Traffic Acquisition. How much comes from “Organic Search” vs “Direct” vs “Social”? Organic should be growing over time.
  • Top pages: Which pages are most visited? Are your service pages getting traffic or just your homepage?

If GA4 isn’t installed on your site, install it now — you’re flying blind without it.

Step 2: Check What You Rank For — Google Search Console

Google Search Console (free) shows you exactly which keywords your site appears for in Google, and how many clicks you’re getting.

What to check:

  • Performance report: Look at your top queries — are these the keywords your actual customers would search?
  • Average position: If you’re ranking in positions 11–20 (page 2), small improvements could significantly increase clicks
  • Click-through rate: If you’re getting impressions but few clicks, your title tags and meta descriptions may need improving
  • Coverage issues: Any pages Google can’t index are invisible to searchers

Step 3: Check Your Site Speed — PageSpeed Insights

Go to pagespeed.web.dev and enter your website URL. Google will score your site from 0–100 on both mobile and desktop.

  • 90+: Excellent
  • 50–89: Needs improvement
  • Under 50: Poor — likely affecting your rankings and losing visitors

Focus on the mobile score — this is what Google uses for ranking. The most common fixes are image compression, caching, and removing unused plugins.

Step 4: Check If Your Contact Form Works

Test your own contact form right now. Submit it and check:

  • Does the submission go through?
  • Do you receive the email notification?
  • Does it end up in spam?
  • Does it work on mobile?

It sounds basic, but broken contact forms are surprisingly common — especially after WordPress updates or email hosting changes. A broken form silently loses every lead that tries to contact you.

Step 5: Check Your Google Business Profile

Search for your business name on Google. Does your GBP listing appear on the right side of the results? Is the information correct? Are your hours up to date? How many reviews do you have compared to competitors ranking above you in the map pack?

Signs Your Website Is Not Working

  • Under 100 organic visitors per month
  • No keywords ranking on page 1 for your core services
  • PageSpeed score under 50 on mobile
  • Contact form hasn’t generated an enquiry in months
  • Most traffic comes from “Direct” (people typing your URL) rather than organic search
  • Your GBP has fewer than 10 reviews and competitors have 50+

What to Do If It’s Not Working

Identifying the problem is half the battle. Common fixes:

  • No traffic: SEO — optimise your service pages, build backlinks, improve your GBP
  • Traffic but no leads: Conversion — improve calls to action, add testimonials, fix the contact form, test your mobile experience
  • Slow site: Speed optimisation — compress images, add caching, upgrade hosting
  • Poor rankings: Content + backlinks — rewrite thin pages, build local citations

At Oop Design, we conduct free website audits for Sunshine Coast businesses. We’ll check all of the above and give you a clear, honest picture of what’s working and what isn’t — with no obligation. Get your free website audit here. Or learn more about our SEO and web design services.

Your Ultimate Solution for Boosting Your Website's Online Visibility, Get in touch today.

Step 1 of 3

Name